Four years after a cattle shipment to China, farmers and other suppliers face repayment demands running into millions. The court record shows who got paid, who missed out, and why the decisions made before the ship sailed still demand answers.
In September 2026, a farming business received a letter demanding nearly $100,000. It had supplied cattle for export to China and been paid in June 2022. The liquidators’ lawyers said they had filed a notice to set the payment aside and warned that fighting the demand could mean additional interest and costs if the liquidators won. The cattle had been gone for four years. The money from their sale was back in dispute.
The letter followed a High Court ruling against Southland Dairies Ltd, a separate livestock supplier. On 14 August 2026, the court ordered it to repay $266,570 to Genetic Development (NZ) Exports Limited Partnership, known as GDX, plus interest from 5 September 2022, the date of liquidation. The repayment included the livestock agent’s commission, even though that sum had been deducted before Southland Dairies received its money. The liquidators were also entitled to costs.
The judgment was a test case. By October, the liquidators said they had sent payment demands to about 100 vendors after the ruling and had started receiving settlement money. Farmers Weekly reported that the wider recovery effort was worth around $9 million. The court also recorded notices to some recipients who supplied goods and services. Trucking companies, livestock agents and other service businesses are among the creditors. Some suppliers face demands for money they received. Others did the work and are still waiting to be paid.
Southland Dairies has appealed. The liquidators’ October report expected a Court of Appeal hearing in the second quarter of 2027. That was their estimate. A confirmed fixture has yet to be independently verified.
The decision to load
The original vessel, the Al Kuwait, developed mechanical problems on its way to New Zealand. The replacement, the Ocean Ute, could carry far fewer cattle. Farmers had already sent stock into pre-export isolation. GDX’s usual trade finance provider declined to open its facility after learning of the ship problem, according to what directors David Hayman and David McEwen told the liquidators.
On 29 April 2022, Hayman told suppliers with cattle near Bulls that GDX was working to secure finance and get them paid. At the second isolation site near Tokoroa, suppliers were asked to agree to local sales on their own account. By 24 May, Hayman was telling larger vendors that trade finance options had been exhausted. He presented an immediate choice. Support the shipment and receive payment within 14 days, or face the prospect of GDX going straight into administration. The cattle began loading at New Plymouth on 27 May.
The deal depended on a letter of credit issued by the Chinese buyer’s bank. Purcell Brothers SPV became the beneficiary and Allied Irish Bank directed proceeds to selected recipients, including the agent for Southland Dairies, Carrfields. For the suppliers covered by that arrangement, the proceeds would bypass GDX’s bank account.
There was a fight over who made the list. Under the deal, about 80 percent of the letter-of-credit proceeds could be assigned irrevocably. GDX was initially offered an assignment that would let it pay livestock vendors without representation. The judge said that plan appeared to unravel in the final days. The ship’s feed supplier wanted its own assignment. Firstlight sought coverage for a second invoice. After the ship sailed, Hayman emailed Purcell asking for the final list and questioning whether the last changes had come at GDX’s expense. McEwen’s subsequent briefing recorded GDX’s belief that smaller direct vendors would be paid from the balance.
The court recorded the result for 31 livestock vendors whose animals sailed on the Ocean Ute without an assignment. Their invoices for that shipment totalled more than $1.07 million and remained unpaid. That figure covers those vendors on that voyage alone. It leaves out the wider pool of unpaid suppliers and service providers.
How a payment became a clawback
Southland Dairies argued that the payment came through an independent arrangement with Purcell and Allied Irish Bank. The High Court found that GDX remained the seller, agreed to the arrangement and used the proceeds to discharge its debt to Southland Dairies. For insolvency purposes, the money counted as a payment by GDX. A payment made while a debtor cannot pay its due debts can be clawed back if it gives a creditor more than it would likely receive in the liquidation and the statutory requirements are met.
The judge also found that Southland Dairies had parted with its cattle before it was paid. Carrfields’ knowledge counted as Southland Dairies’ knowledge in this case, and the court concluded that the company had failed to establish the insolvency-suspicion element of its defence. The court left good faith undecided. The judge acknowledged the individual hardship of making a supplier return payment for livestock it had delivered, and said that any distribution it might ultimately get from the liquidation would likely be far smaller.
Several livestock businesses later told Farmers Weekly they believed they had been misled. One said it had understood Purcell was taking over the shipment. Patrick Purcell told the publication he had been approached by a third party to help get farmers paid and had no view of GDX’s accounts. The judgment records an informal agreement between GDX and Purcells’ Australian business in early May about future export collaboration, alongside the Irish entity’s role in the May shipment. The allegation of deception from the outset remains unproven. The emails and payment records raise a narrower question the directors can answer. When the allocations changed, who told the suppliers left outside the arrangement what they could realistically expect?
The directors and the business that carried on
The limited partnership went into liquidation. Its corporate general partner was GDNZ Management Ltd, whose directors the 2026 judgment identifies as Hayman, McEwen and Jin Ding. By October 2022, Farmers Weekly reported that Hayman was back in live exports through HerdBuilder Export Services Ltd, which also listed McEwen as a director. HerdBuilder predated the liquidation and was previously called Genetic Development (NZ) Ltd. Hayman said in a separate court case that the name change was intended to reassure customers and industry contacts that HerdBuilder itself was outside the liquidation.
That separate case shows what the distinction meant to one supplier. AsureQuality issued a statutory demand against HerdBuilder for an unpaid $350,058.85 services invoice. It said HerdBuilder was its contracting party. HerdBuilder said GDX owed the invoice. Hayman acknowledged signing shipment paperwork that still referred to the earlier company, saying he had overlooked the reference in a template under time pressure. In April 2023, the High Court set aside the demand because there was an arguable substantial dispute about which entity owed the debt. The ruling left ultimate liability for the invoice open.
What about phoenixing? The Companies Act offence concerns specified involvement with a business using the same name, or one similar enough to suggest an association, in the five years after an insolvent company’s liquidation, subject to exceptions and court permission. The distinction between GDX and its general partner matters here. Section 92 of the Limited Partnerships Act applies the Companies Act’s Part 16 liquidation provisions, including clawbacks, to a limited partnership. The phoenix offence sits in Part 21. Any enforcement case would need a legal basis tied to the relevant entity and individuals.
In 2022, liquidator Malcolm Hollis told Farmers Weekly that his preliminary view was that the phoenix rules had not been breached and that he would look at the issue. The October 2026 report says the two New Zealand-based directors cooperated and provided records. It also says the liquidators are still investigating the directors’ actions for potential recoveries or referrals. Four years after the liquidation, the records reviewed for this article disclose no charge, final enforcement decision or documented transfer of GDX assets or contracts to HerdBuilder.
There are questions the directors can answer directly. What did they know about GDX’s ability to pay when they urged suppliers to release their cattle? Who approved the final payment list? Did any contracts, customers, staff, assets or revenue move to HerdBuilder, and what did GDX receive if they did? The liquidators and the Registrar can answer a related question about what has been investigated, referred or decided. Farmers and other suppliers have been told, down to the dollar, what the liquidators want back. They deserve the same precision about the decisions that left them carrying the loss.
